So, when shopping at SELWG, a box set of the Fireforge Templar Knights ended up being the solution, and here they (already) are:
I recycled some very old Space Marine waterslide transfers for these, as my painting isn’t neat enough to do sharp-edged crosses
The guy (or as they are a kit, the arm) with the flail is pretty cool. The sprues come with more than one of these so my next Almughavar base may end up with a guy armed with this too!
More upcycled Space Marine graphics – I very roughly painted in some extra texture into the white-only transfers of the Pegasus and the stag’s head to give them a bit more depth.
This guy doesn’t have a weird helmet – its the mace of the guy in the middle (who also has a GB Arab head to make these feel a bit more El Cid “Spanish Reconquista” era)
The painting-in is more visible here on the barding
Every time I do it I regret starting a check pattern, but this one is not too bad IMO

Gertrude is a research journalist working performing her duties as chief editor at this news station. She is a talented writer and comes up with facts everybody wants to know.